Nags Head, NC, Restaurants: Italian

Italian fare is the ultimate crowd pleaser. Just about everyone can be satisfied with this choice. Italian-themed Nags Head, NC, restaurants include pizza places, but some offer more than just pizza to include lasagna, ziti, manicotti and other Italian favorites.

Benny Tesoro's Pizza

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

Benny Tesoro's is the 30th location in the Benny's chain of pizzerias that includes locations in Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Pennsylvania and Wyoming. Each location has a slightly different name reflecting the town it is in. Tesoro means treasure in Italian, a word meant to reflect the legendary pirate treasure in Nags Head. Benny Tesoro's specializes in huge 28" pizzas and huge slices. Their...read more

Lucky 12 Tavern

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

This neighborhood tavern serves quality food at great prices. Lucky 12 has fresh local seafood, hand-patted burgers, great New York-style pizza, authentic Buffalo chicken wings and Boardwalk Fries. Everything is fresh and well-prepared, and the chef creates tasty daily specials. There's a menu for kids. The dining room is open for lunch and dinner. The bar is also a popular late-night hangout, and...read more

Nags Head Pizza Company

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

Nags Head Pizza Company has moved from the Nags Head-Manteo Causeway to a new location on the beach road in Nags Head. The owners fixed up a 1960s brick building in the heart of historic row, and it looks amazing. While the location is new, the food is the same – thank goodness! Nags Head Pizza Company is known for its fresh healthy salads and...read more

Pizzazz Pizza

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

Pizzazz is a pizza favorite on the Outer Banks. They’ve been around since 1986 because they make consistently great pizza with generous toppings and the service is friendly. Choose from gourmet menu creations or stick with the traditional. Pizzazz also makes hot subs, salads and wings. You can eat in for lunch or dinner or have your pizza delivered. Call for off-season hours. And, if...read more

Village Pizza

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

Village Pizza, located beside the big yellow Oceans store (next to Sonic) in the Village at Nags Head, is a locally owned and operated restaurant offering delicious New York-style pizza. Build your own pizza from a variety of toppings or choose one of their specialty pies. They also offer garlic knots, several flavors of jumbo wings, sandwiches and subs, fries and salads, which can be...read more

Yellow Submarine

Nags Head, NC, Italian

Contact info

Yellow Submarine features hot and cold specialty subs featuring Boar's Head meats. Definitely try their Philly Cheese Steak Sub — it’s great! They also offer pizza and fresh salads. Kids dig the chicken tenders and their own specialty pizzas and will stay entertained with the video games. Beverages include beer on tap, soft drinks and tea. Eat-in or take-out service is available, as...read more