Nags Head, NC, Restaurants: Pizza

Ahhh, pizza – so yummy, so convenient, so beloved by so many. When you’re looking for pizza from Nags Head, NC, restaurants you have a wealth of choices. There are choices for dine-in, take-out and pizza delivery in Nags Head, NC, so you can easily feed your family or the crowd of people staying in your vacation rental. Keep in mind that pizza delivery is extremely popular on vacation rental check-in days, so if you have the same idea, order early. Who has the best pizza in Nags Head, NC? We wouldn’t dare say, as pizza is an entirely subjective subject. Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings vary from place to place, so finding the best pizza in Nags Head, NC, is something you’ll have to do on your own.

Featured for Your Visit

Dunes Restaurant

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

7013 S. Virginia Dare Trail, Between The Bypass and The Beach Road, MP 16.5, Nags Head

(252) 441-1600

Dunes Restaurant has been a breakfast and dinner favorite among Outer Banks locals and visitors for more than four decades. Breakfast here is a certifiable Nags Head tradition. Their hearty meals and platters are a huge draw, and their breakfast menu is one of the biggest on the beach, with choices like shrimp and grits, creamed chipped beef, N.C. country ham, a crab and shrimp...read more

Dunes Restaurant has been a breakfast and dinner favorite among Outer Banks locals and visitors...read more

The Fudgery

1177 Duck Road, Scarborough Lane Shopping Center, Duck

(252) 255-0993

790-M Ocean Trail, Space A, Corolla

(252) 453-8882

3933 S. Croatan Highway, The Bypass, MP 12, Nags Head

(252) 480-0163

Website

Facebook

Coupon

Don’t you hate it when people say that chocolate fudge is sinful? Sometimes it’s just a necessity. The Fudgery’s creamy concoctions can satisfy any sweet tooth. Your mind will be boggled at the variety of flavors from dark chocolate to peanut butter to rocky road, even New Orleans praline. The fudge is all theatrically prepared right in front of your eyes on marble slabs and...read more

Don’t you hate it when people say that chocolate fudge is sinful? Sometimes it’s just...read more

Almost Heaven Bakery OBX

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

In Pirates Quay Shopping Center, this bakery does not hold back on the deliciousness. You’ll find pies, cakes, cookies and pastries in the cases at all times, and they make custom cakes. They’re open Wednesday through Saturday, but you can call anytime for custom orders.read more

Benny Tesoro's Pizza

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

Benny Tesoro's is the 30th location in the Benny's chain of pizzerias that includes locations in Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Pennsylvania and Wyoming. Each location has a slightly different name reflecting the town it is in. Tesoro means treasure in Italian, a word meant to reflect the legendary pirate treasure in Nags Head. Benny Tesoro's specializes in huge 28" pizzas and huge slices. Their...read more

Blue Moon Beach Grill

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

In a marvelous, brand-new building a half-mile south of its original location, Blue Moon Beach Grill has evolved from a small, casual grill into a full-fledged dining experience that's bursting with energy. A Nags Head favorite since 2009, Blue Moon serves creative, chef-prepared Southern coastal comfort food, plentiful local seafood, Wagyu burgers, all-natural meats, salads and more, with a menu that includes something for everyone...read more

Booty Treats Ice Cream & Shave Ice

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

Booty Treats Ice Cream & Shave Ice offers authentic Hawaiian Shave Ice, old-fashioned malts, milkshakes and sundaes, as well as a variety of tasty Booty original favorites like the Booty Freeze, a unique blend of Mini-Melts ice cream and Hawaiian Shave Ice, a combination only found at Booty Treats! In addition to their original spot in Nags Head, Booty Treats now has a second location on...read more

Cahoon’s Market

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

This vintage, family-owned grocery store offers fresh meats, a great selection of fine wines and a variety of groceries. They have gourmet cheeses and pates, homegrown vegetables, herbs, spices, sauces and marinades. Cahoon's offers delicious homemade sandwich fixings (tuna salad, chicken salad, pimento cheese) that are easy to pick up on your way to the beach, along with all the chips, beer, sodas...read more

Coastal Creamery

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

Coastal Creamery serves hand-scooped ice cream, soft-serve and Italian ice. You'll find it in Nags Head near Tanger Outlets and the bumper boats, mini golf and go kart places. They have indoor seating and nice porch seating with a view.read more

Cookies & Cream

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

What's better than a cool ice cream treat? Warm cookies and a glass of milk! You can have it all at this creamery and bakery in Nags Head. Enjoy cookies and a glass of milk or an ice cream cone – or put them all together in a shake known as a Combine. Cookies & Cream serves ice cream and milk from Homestead Creamery in...read more

Dirty Dick’s Crab House

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

You can find Dirty Dick’s at two locations on the Outer Banks – in Nags Head on the Bypass and on Hatteras Island in the same shopping center as Food Lion in Avon. Judging by the name, this might sound like a simple seafood shack, but Dirty Dick’s is actually a nice restaurant with a fun-loving atmosphere and seriously good food. The menu pays homage...read more

Duck Donuts

Contact info

Make a beeline for Duck Donuts where you will find warm, delicious and made-to-order donuts. Duck Donuts makes its donuts fresh on site, and you have the option of each one being coasted in powdered or cinnamon sugar or dipped in vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, lemon, peanut butter or maple glaze then sprinkled with your favorite toppings. You can watch your donuts being made then have...read more

Dune Burger

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

At Dune Burger you can enjoy fast food-style favorites like hamburgers, hot dogs, barbecue, french fries and ice cream. What could be better in the summertime? This is a to-go stop only, but they do have a few picnic tables outside if you'd like to eat it there. It's right across the street from Jennette's Pier and has been a locals'favorite for years. Dune Burger...read more

Dune Street Rawbar & Grill

Nags Head, NC, Restaurant

Contact info

Dune Street Rawbar & Grill is a new Nags Head restaurant tucked in the corner of Surfside Plaza. The restaurant is spacious, and the ambiance is vibrant and lively, usually with a crowd of locals tucked around the center bar. The inventive menu focuses on seafood, but there are other specialties to satisfy all palates. It's open for dinner only, but they are planning to...read more